Barry Schwartz called it the tyranny of choice. His argument was that past a certain point, more options leave us less satisfied, and sometimes stop us choosing at all.
Music and TV hit it first. About 106,000 new tracks were delivered to streaming services every day last year, and 120 million tracks got ten plays or fewer. In a 2015 paper, Netflix's product leads wrote that a typical member loses interest after 60 to 90 seconds of choosing, having looked at 10 to 20 titles. That's why so much of what we watch and hear is now picked for us.
Now it's software's turn. For almost every job there used to be one major player. Now there are hundreds, if not thousands. The 2025 marketing technology landscape counted 15,384 products, about 100 times as many as in 2011. One AI directory, There's An AI For That, lists 988 AI tools for social media alone, many of them do-it-for-you options like Holo, Predis.ai and Ocoya.
When the choice is overwhelming, we lean towards the familiar, even when it isn't the best for us. Psychologists call it status quo bias. We do it in relationships, in housing, in work. It even shows up in pensions: in a study of 649 US retirement plans, every ten extra funds on the menu meant about 2% fewer people signed up at all.
Music has its own name for it: musical paralysis. A Deezer survey found people in the UK stop discovering new music at around 30, and one in five blamed being overwhelmed by choice. So we replay what we know. Brain scans back it up: familiar songs light up our reward circuitry more than unfamiliar ones.
If you're building something, that's the real competition. You're not up against the best option. You're up against the familiar one.
Infinite choice doesn't set us free. It steers us back to the familiar.
🎵 Four Tops — It's the Same Old Song Motown needed a follow-up to a No. 1, fast, so they built it on much the same chords. It went top five. Full playlist and archive at niccjohnson.com/drop.